Ad: BlueJ Better Tax Answers. -Accomplish hours of research in seconds -Instantly draft high-quality communications -Verify answers using a library of trusted tax content. Learn more

Distilling the Limits of the Taxing Power

Marie Sapirie has a new Tax Notes article on the Supreme Court’s McNutt case, “Distilling the Necessary and Proper Limits of the Tax Power” (Nov. 16, 2026). Here is a taste:

Use of the necessary and proper clause to try to salvage a questionable assertion of the taxing power has been causing consternation in appellate and district courts lately. The Supreme Court will resolve the pressing issue of whether the code’s prohibition on backyard booze production is necessary and proper for carrying out the taxing power. The vintage of the statute in dispute dates to 1868, making this one of the more unique tax cases, but one that has important implications.

In the case, McNutt v. Department of Justice, No. 24-10760 (5th Cir. 2026), the Fifth Circuit held that the ban on home distilling violated both the taxing power and the necessary and proper clause. . . .

The first point to note about the prohibition on home distilling is that it was written in 1868 and has remained unchanged since — quite a feat in the tax code, and one that suggests a heavy dose of legislative inertia. The second point is that it isn’t the only statutory problem for the would-be domestic distillers. Section 5203(b) gives IRS agents authority “to enter any distilled spirits plant, or any other premises where distilled spirits operations are carried on . . . to make examination of the materials, equipment, and facilities thereon.” Section 5203(d) similarly permits revenue officers to “break up the ground on any part of a distilled spirits plant or any other premises where distilled spirits operations are carried on” to search for pipes concealing any booze or liquor precursors. It isn’t clear that the IRS or one of its predecessors ever used this extraordinary destructive authority, but the petitioners would presumably not like to have these rules applied to their home distilleries any more than the prohibition they complain of.


About the Author

Ad: BlueJ Better Tax Answers. Blue J's generative AI tax research solution is transforming how tax experts work. Learn more.
Information and rates on advertising on TaxProf Blog