Ad: BlueJ Better Tax Answers. -Accomplish hours of research in seconds -Instantly draft high-quality communications -Verify answers using a library of trusted tax content. Learn more

TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program

TIGTA The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration yesterday released First-Time Homebuyer Credit Repayment Notices Were Incorrect, and the Method Used to Identify Dispositions Is Unreliable (2011-41-097):

Each of the laws which provide First-Time Homebuyer Credits (Homebuyer Credit) contains different Homebuyer Credit amounts, qualification requirements, and repayment requirements. Our review identified inaccuracies relating to the issuance of Homebuyer Credit repayment notices. …

The IRS reported a total of $29.7 billion in Homebuyer Credit claims were made by more than 4 million individuals as of May 7, 2011. Our overall objective was to evaluate the effectiveness of IRS processes to ensure the accurate and timely repayment of the Homebuyer Credit. …

The IRS issued incorrect notices or did not send notices to 61,427 households due to notice programming errors or incorrect information on tax account. … [O]ur review of the third-party vendor’s research results for a statistically valid sample of 97 taxpayer accounts determined that for 40 (41%) of the taxpayer accounts, the information provided to the IRS had incomplete or inaccurate information.


About the Author

Ad: BlueJ Better Tax Answers. Blue J's generative AI tax research solution is transforming how tax experts work. Learn more.
Information and rates on advertising on TaxProf Blog

9 responses to “TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program”

  1. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  2. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  3. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  4. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  5. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  6. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  7. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  8. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  9. Roth & Company, P.C. Avatar

    Boy, that home-buyer credit was a great idea

    From the TaxProf: TIGTA: 41% Error Rate in $30 Billion First Time Homebuyer Tax Credit Program From the TIGTA report:…

  10. American Delight Avatar

    Okay, the IRS had 61,000 wrong or unsent notices out of 4 million. That’s insignificant. They were doing their best to implement a flawed policy.
    The blame, it would seem, falls on the 40 percent of claimants who submitted bad information. I guess they thought they could claim the credit without having to actually fill out each line of the form they were signing.

  11. Slartibartfast Avatar
    Slartibartfast

    You didn’t read to the end:

    [O]ur review of the third-party vendor’s research results for a statistically valid sample of 97 taxpayer accounts determined that for 40 (41%) of the taxpayer accounts, the information provided to the IRS had incomplete or inaccurate information.

    That is a completely different point than the point that the IRS had failed to mail notices regarding homebuyer tax credit to 61k homes.
    Or you can read the report itself, which TaxProf has kindly linked.

  12. Walt C Avatar
    Walt C

    Yeah, these are the guys I want administering my health care.
    Can anyone name one program that the gov’t has ever handled efficiently?
    Even the military (as good at destroying things as they are) is woefully inefficient when it comes to handling money or resources.

  13. Harry Schell Avatar
    Harry Schell

    Is the tax code now past even its minders being able to do a decent job with it?

  14. Daniel Avatar
    Daniel

    The IRS is making a worldwide push to squeeze money from Americans living abroad and from anyone who holds dual citizenship, whether they know it or not. It doesn’t matter if the “duals” want US status, have never set foot on US soil, or never conducted business with an American. I have experienced a lot of IRS problems since i move out of the U.S. My advice is to hire a CPA specialized in expat taxes for your tax returns if you live abroad.

  15. American Delight Avatar

    Slartibartfast, I too was making two separate points.