Ad: BlueJ Better Tax Answers. -Accomplish hours of research in seconds -Instantly draft high-quality communications -Verify answers using a library of trusted tax content. Learn more

Norm Macdonald, Death, and God

Following up on my 2021 post on Norm Macdonald after his death (New York Times, Norm Macdonald’s Comedy Was Quite Christian): Law & Liberty, Laughing Matters:

Once you’re familiar enough with the late Norm Macdonald’s comedy, something interesting happens: you start laughing at the beginning of the joke more than the end. That’s because Norm was a master of “spinning a yarn,” and the humor was often less in the punch line and more in the entirety of the tale that he told and the purpose for which he chose to tell it. As soon as he starts to tell a story with a twinkle in the eye, the laughter begins in anticipation.

He also regularly made his own life story into a bit of a tall tale, not just in stand-up, but also in interviews and other “serious” formats. The culmination of that practice was his brilliantly fake “memoir,” Based on a True Story. But in countless interviews, when he casually dropped little tidbits about his life, from his education to his drinking habits to whether he was a “deeply closeted gay guy,” one could never quite tell whether what he said was true, an exaggeration, a straightforward joke, or intentional obfuscation. …

It’s no coincidence, then, that the new Netflix documentary on his life directed by Judd Apatow is subtitled The Tale of Norm Macdonald. The “tale” is made up entirely of archived footage, and its only narration comes from Norm himself, taken from the audiobook of the above-mentioned memoir or from other interviews. It aims more at that overarching, ineffable truth that Norm described—something you can observe in a life, but can’t quite write down. …

When one sees through the BS and self-importance that swirls all around us, it’s very easy to become smug and overly impressed with oneself. Other comedians, such as Bill Maher or Ricky Gervais, for instance, poke at many of the same pretentions that Norm did, but Norm never displayed the kind of sneering pride that they often exude. One reason for that, perhaps, was his lifelong contemplation of his own mortality and serious wrestling with religious faith. And wrestling is the right word. He was clearly haunted by a sense of meaninglessness without God. But he also didn’t see faith as something that comes easily, or that can just be tried out like a new hobby. He was certainly nobody’s version of a “Christian comedian”—some of his bits are as raunchy and obscene as one will find anywhere. He often observed that his own Christian faith was shaky and always in contest with doubt. “It seems like faith is the only salvation,” he says at one point, “but I don’t know how to get it.”

Several comments from his final years put one in mind of Ecclesiastes. There was deep anxiety about death; an uneasy recognition that the things of the world are vanity. But also a simple joy for the things he has. “We’re all just lucky,” he says in a characteristically bizarre formulation (and in a very sickly voice) “that we can go outside, eat at Denny’s, and wear a hat.” Apatow’s “tale” gives the audience a brief glimpse at an interesting man’s life and does not try to tell a moral at the end. That’s for the best. If there is something to learn from Norm’s story—equally hilarious, poignant, hopeful, and melancholy—it probably won’t fit into a neat box. Maybe the best one can do is to say that there is a time to weep and a time to laugh.

Editor’s Note:  If you would like to receive a weekly email each Sunday with links to faith posts on TaxProf Blog, email me here.


About the Author

Ad: BlueJ Better Tax Answers. Blue J's generative AI tax research solution is transforming how tax experts work. Learn more.
Information and rates on advertising on TaxProf Blog